Pin it
These homemade Oreo cookies are my favorite way to recreate a nostalgic treat in my own kitchen. They deliver that signature crisp chocolate shell and creamy filling, but you get to control the flavors and make them as thick or thin as you want. Whenever my house smells like baking chocolate cookies, someone always asks for another batch.
I first made these to surprise my brother for his birthday and now he requests them every year. It feels extra special serving up handmade cookies that bring people together around the kitchen table.
Ingredients
- All purpose flour: gives the cookies structure Aim for unbleached flour for best texture
- Dutch process or black cocoa powder: adds a deep chocolate note Use black cocoa for that classic Oreo color and taste
- Baking soda and baking powder: give the cookies a little lift while keeping the bite crisp
- Salt: tightens and balances the sweetness A fine sea salt works best
- Granulated sugar: sweetens the cookies and encourages crisp edges Opt for organic sugar for a pure flavor
- Unsalted butter: binds everything together and makes the cookies crumbly but tender Choose good quality European style if possible for richer flavor
- Large egg: brings the dough together and gives a slight chew Make sure it is room temperature so it blends evenly
- For the filling soft unsalted butter: creates that creamy classic texture Go with fresh butter for best results
- Pure vanilla extract: adds aroma and sweet depth Always check for true vanilla instead of imitation
- Powdered sugar: sifted for smoothness and a snowy finish Quality powdered sugar helps prevent lumps
- Fine sea salt in the filling: sharpens the flavors just right
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make the Dough:
- Combine the flour cocoa powder baking soda baking powder salt and sugar either in your food processor or mixer Mix on low until just blended
- Add the Butter and Egg:
- With the mixer on low or while pulsing the processor add butter a few pieces at a time until you have a sandy crumb Add the egg and mix until the dough just clumps together This takes around one minute
- Shape the Cookies:
- Scoop one tablespoon portions of dough and space them widely on lined baking sheets Dampen your hand and flatten each ball evenly to about one eighth inch thickness The dampness keeps the dough from sticking
- Chill the Cookie Rounds:
- Slide the baking trays into the fridge for at least ten minutes Chilling helps the cookies bake up neat and hold their shape
- Bake the Cookies:
- Bake in a preheated oven at three hundred seventy five degrees Fahrenheit for nine to ten minutes Turn the pans halfway through so every cookie bakes evenly
- Cool the Cookies:
- Let the cookies rest on the baking sheets for a few minutes to set Then move to a rack to cool completely so they become crisp
- Mix the Filling:
- With a mixer beat the soft butter and vanilla until creamy Scrape down the sides Gradually mix in powdered sugar and salt Beat for two to three minutes until the filling is fluffy and light
- Assemble the Sandwiches:
- Pipe or spread a teaspoon of filling on the bottom of one cookie Top with a matching cookie and press gently so the filling spreads Repeat for all pairs
Pin it
I always sneak extra vanilla into the filling because the aroma brings back memories of baking with my grandma She taught me that a pinch of salt in the filling really wakes up the flavor and every batch since has tasted more balanced
Storage Tips
Store assembled cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days For best crunch enjoy them the day you make them If you have more than you can eat freeze the unfilled cookies layered between parchment in a zip bag then fill them fresh when ready
Ingredient Substitutions
You can substitute Dutch process cocoa for black cocoa but the flavor will be more mellow and the cookies lighter in color For dairy free cookies use vegan butter in both the dough and filling Just make sure it is firm enough to hold the texture well
Serving Suggestions
Serve homemade Oreos with a glass of cold milk or tuck them into lunchboxes for a special treat They are perfect for sharing at bake sales or adding to ice cream for a fun dessert twist
A Bit of History
Did you know that the Oreo as we know it first appeared in the early twentieth century This homemade version channels those roots but gives you full creative control From flavoring the filling with mint or adding espresso powder to the dough there is room for fun kitchen experiments
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which cocoa powder is best for homemade sandwich cookies?
Black cocoa powder gives the most authentic flavor and color, but Dutch-process cocoa works well, producing a lighter cookie with a slightly different taste.
- → How should I achieve the signature sandwich cookie texture?
Chill flattened dough before baking and avoid overbaking. This helps create cookies that are crisp yet tender enough to sandwich.
- → Can I add flavors to the filling?
Yes! Mix in extracts like peppermint or almond, or even cocoa for a chocolate filling. Adjust flavorings to your liking.
- → How can I make double-stuffed cookies?
Simply pipe or spread a thicker layer of the vanilla filling before sandwiching the cookies together.
- → How long do homemade sandwich cookies stay fresh?
They're best enjoyed the same day, but can be stored in an airtight container for up to 2 days. The cookies may soften slightly over time.
- → Can I make the dough ahead of time?
Yes, the dough can be prepared and chilled up to 24 hours in advance, making it convenient for baking later.